Luna
Luna
By Katherine Scalia
Green Mountain Valley School, Grade 10
Luna…
was my
brother's first
word. It must
have been the
Spanish nanny
who would point at
the dimpled fluorescent
sphere lighting up the sky
and brightly say, “Look
little Nicolás! They hung
it there for you! It shines
that big for you!...
la luna, la luna,
shines like that
for you…”
Luna…

UVM Mentor Comment
Hi Katherine,
I really liked this poem! My family spends every summer on Cape Cod, and when my cousin Michelena was little, the only words she could say for a long time were "da boats!" and "da moon!" I think I liked your poem so much because it made me think of her; it's so interesting what little ones' first words are, and it's neat that your little brother and my little cousin have that first word in common!
I also thought that your poem was really well written. It flowed really well, and I feel like it was the perfect length. Really the only editing suggestions I would make are a couple of little grammar mistakes: "brothers" should be "brother's" because it was his first word and therefore belongs to him, and you forgot to capitalize "Spanish" in the sixth line. Other than that I thought it was pretty flawless.
One thing you might think about doing is writing a series of poems kind of like this about your baby brother; I think that would be really cool. Of course, you don't want to over do it, but I think talking about his first word or his first steps or other important firsts would be a really cool combination of works. I'd try another one and see how you like it. It could end up being a really nice gift for him or for your parents.
Best,
Tressie
UVM Mentor